Thursday, September 10, 2009

Dealing with uncertainties in carbon price

The main difference between a carbon tax (emissions tax) and an emissions trading scheme is this. With a carbon tax, the price of emitting a unit of greenhouse gases is fixed but the total level of emissions is unknown. With an emissions trading scheme, the level of emissions is fixed (capped) but the price is unknown.

It follows that choosing one over the other is partly an issue of whether you want certainty in your environmental outcome or certainty in the cost to industry.

The experience of the European emissions trading scheme and now it seems the US Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI, pronounce it 'Reggie' - a trading scheme involving 10 States in north-east USA) has been that the cap on emissions was set too high and too many permits made available, with high volatility in permit prices and permit prices crashing after a while. The governments were too worried about the potential cost to indsutry (which isn't known in a trading scheme, but has to be forecast) and so overallocated permits.

Australia's ETS will actually start out as effectively a carbon tax, because the price of permits will be fixed at $10 a tonne for at least the first year. After that it become a trading scheme, with a fixed emissions cap and an unknown permit price.

Actually, it's more like hybrid scheme in one way, because it's proposed that there will be a ceiling price of $40 a tonne: companies can buy unlimited permits from the government at that price, so the permit price will never rise above $40.

A lesson from the EU and RGGI is that it would make sense to set a floor price too, so everyone knows that the permit price will never fall below, for example, $15 a tonne. That gives some certainty to industry, that investments in emissions-reducing technologies that are profitable at a carbon price of $10 a tonne or more can be made with no carbon price risk. It gives some reassurance to renewable energy and similar industries that they can safely invest. And it means that if reducing emissions turns out to be cheaper than expected, some of the benefit goes to the environment in the form of lower emissions and doesn't all go to indsutry in the form of cheaper permits.

12 comments:

Unknown said...

This article is mind blowing. When I read this article, I enjoyed.

Managed IT

Loanoffer said...

Do you need Personal Loan?
Business Cash Loan?
Unsecured Loan
Fast and Simple Loan?
Quick Application Process?
Approvals within 24-72 Hours?
No Hidden Fees Loan?
Funding in less than 1 Week?
Get unsecured working capital?
Contact Us At housingfinance22@gmail.com
Contact us on whatspp +447513195409
Mr Osman Ibrahim

Nicole said...

Whew! Carbon Tax sound silly as its name, knowing everywhere there's traces of carbon.

try us out said...

Everything in this world has carbon, therefore we can't really be a carbon-free world technically. Probably, carbon reduction is the word.

https://ogdenfences.com/ said...

This is just another brick in the wall?

oldsoul1508 said...

I was a little bit confused. Thank you for this information, it lightened me.

https://paintinglongisland.net

find out more said...

Never thought this topic can be very interesting, maybe because of the interesting facts?

Click here said...

Sometimes opinions are doubted, not until the facts slowly coming out in every direction.

treeservicehuntington.com said...

Our climate is already shifting slowly, now the carbon emissions are too huge for our trees and plants to handle, if we do not act right now, then we shall not be assuming a better future. It's real talk.

michelkahaleh.com said...

Due to the COVID-19 situation, virtual care providers experienced a surge in appointments, so people have been experiencing longer wait times to access an appointment compared to a few months ago. Fortunately, as care providers quickly ramped up capacity, those wait times have been coming down.

therufflifemobile.com/ said...

Not unless we feel the real effects of carbon emissions, then we can tell ourselves it is not worth the price.

Anonymous said...


I'm giving gratitude to Mr Pedro for all of his help in securing our loan for our new home here in Fruitland. You were organized & thorough & professional, as well as kind which made all of the difference in our interactions with you. We put our trust in you and you most definitely came through for us. Thank you for your patience as well as treating us as people rather than just home loan customers. You stand above the rest, I want to recommend anyone here looking for loan or investors to contact Mr Pedro and his staff because they are good people with gentle heart,
Mr Pedro Email Contact : pedroloanss@gmail.com



Regards,
John Burley! Our hats off to you!!"